Jai-alai Question of the Week


Start of Thread Re(1): Juggling not supposed to be a foul anyhow

Posted on November 30, 2009 at 10:14:12 PM by Perry

Ummmmm.....that's not 'the rule'. It's 'one of the rules'. Specifically, it's the rule at Dania. At Orlando, the 'juggling or holding' rule says "A player will be whistled when the judge observes the ball out of control in his cesta. Any alteration or stopping of his throwing motion to try and control such a ball constitutes holding." The Miami program doesn't contain their juggling rule, so I have no clue what the rule is supposed to be there. Going back a little further, the Newport program contained the following: "Holding or juggling. This occurs when a player, in the opinion of the court judges, fails to use one continuous motion, retains the ball in the cesta longer than a reasonable time in his attempt to make a play, or allows the ball to leave the cesta (juggling) in a manner that indicated the player has lost control of the ball."

The Orlando and Newport rules seem to say that juggling, in and of itself, is a foul. The Dania rule, on the other hand, says that juggling is not a foul unless the player also holds the ball.

Replies:

Home Page