Since I suggested this question originally all those years ago,
I guess I should answer.
The easy answer would be Urtaran, but I voted for him last year
(2006.)
Another player who has been voted on the past few years is Hernandez...and
he deserves some consideration again because he has now put himself
into a position where he is one of the absolute best in the back
at Dania (and has brought up his singles game too.)